Best Restaurants in Westchester County by Ron Wechsler
|
The Sound Shore isn't just a commute between NYC and Connecticut — it's one of the most underrated food corridors in the Northeast, packed with old-school Italian joints, hidden BYOs, and slice shops locals actually fight over. This guide is for anyone within a 30-minute drive of Mamaroneck, Port Chester, or Rye who's tired of Google's algorithm-ranked lists and wants the real spots — the ones a well-traveled, no-nonsense sports exec actually returns to.
About this guide
Ron isn't a food critic chasing press releases — he's a global sports exec who's eaten his way through cities on every continent, then came home and still keeps going back to the same neighborhood spots. These 21 picks span 7 categories (overall favorites, hidden dishes, date night, cheap eats, pizza, seafood, and Italian) because no single "best of" list captures how people actually eat — sometimes you want a $12 slice, sometimes you want the tasting menu. Every spot made the cut because it earned a repeat visit, not because it was trending or paid for placement — the same "no gatekeepers" standard behind every GrubTok guide.
Restaurants in this guide
-
Pizzeria La Rosa
Pizzeria La Rosa specializes in authentic Neapolitan-style, wood-fired pizzas, complemented by a selection of classic Italian appetizers such as arancini and meatballs, fresh salads, and pasta dishes. They focus on high-quality ingredients and traditional preparation.
-
Goosefeather
Modern Hong Kong cuisine featuring dim sum, noodles, roasted meats, and contemporary Chinese dishes by Chef Dale Talde.
-
Anthony's Delicatessen
Anthony's Delicatessen offers a wide array of classic Italian-American deli fare, including a variety of hot and cold heroes, custom sandwiches, salads, and daily hot entrees like chicken cutlets and eggplant parmesan. They are well-regarded for their fresh ingredients and generous portions, catering to both individual orders and larger events.
-
Sal's Pizza Mamaroneck
Sal's Pizza Mamaroneck offers classic New York-style pizza, a variety of pasta dishes, hot and cold heroes, salads, and other Italian-American comfort food in a casual setting.
-
Rowayton Seafood
Rowayton Seafood offers a refined menu focused on fresh, high-quality seafood, including an extensive raw bar, grilled fish, lobster, and creative seafood preparations. They also feature select non-seafood entrees like steaks, complemented by a curated wine list and craft cocktails.
-
Felice Port Chester
Felice Port Chester offers a traditional Tuscan menu with a focus on fresh, seasonal ingredients. The menu includes a variety of antipasti, house-made pastas, wood-fired pizzas, classic meat and fish secondi, and Italian desserts, complemented by an extensive wine list and full bar.
-
Original Emilios Brick Oven
A local Italian-American eatery specializing in brick oven pizzas, alongside a menu of classic pasta dishes, hot and cold heroes, fresh salads, and appetizers.
-
Talia
Talia offers a modern Italian and Mediterranean menu featuring fresh pasta, seafood, grilled meats, and a variety of appetizers and desserts.
-
Orienta Restaurant
A sophisticated blend of classic French culinary techniques and vibrant Vietnamese flavors, featuring dishes like pho, spring rolls, steak frites, and creative seafood.
-
Taqueria La Picardia
This compact spot with a funky, laid-back vibe serves tacos, fajitas & other Mexican staples.
-
Pizza Fenice
Pizza Fenice offers a wide selection of traditional and gourmet pizzas, alongside classic Italian dishes such as pasta, salads, appetizers, and heroes.
-
Telly’s Taverna Of Port Chester
Telly's Taverna offers a menu of traditional Greek and Mediterranean cuisine, featuring fresh seafood, grilled meats, classic mezes, and a variety of salads and vegetarian options.
-
TVB by: Pax Romana
-
Villa Rustica Trattoria
A traditional Italian trattoria offering a wide range of classic pasta dishes, pizzas, seafood, and meat entrees, alongside appetizers and salads.
-
1881 Kitchen Table
1881 Kitchen Table offers modern American cuisine with a significant Mediterranean influence, focusing on fresh, seasonal ingredients. The menu features a variety of appetizers, pasta dishes, seafood, and meat entrees like steak and lamb chops. They also serve a brunch menu.
-
Augustine’s Salumeria e Pasta Joint
An Italian eatery specializing in a variety of cured meats, cheeses, and fresh pasta dishes.
-
Crust Issues Pizza
Crust Issues Pizza specializes in artisanal pizzas with a focus on high-quality ingredients and creative flavor combinations. They offer a variety of classic and gourmet pizzas, including options for gluten-free crusts and vegan cheese, alongside appetizers and salads.
-
Dunwoodie Pizzeria
Offers a selection of classic New York-style pizzas, pasta dishes, hot and cold heroes, salads, and appetizers.
-
Ruby's Oyster Bar & Bistro
Ruby's Oyster Bar & Bistro offers a menu centered around fresh oysters, a variety of seafood dishes, and classic American bistro fare, including salads, sandwiches, and entrees, complemented by a full bar.
-
25 North
25 North offers a modern Italian-American menu featuring classic Italian dishes with a contemporary twist, including pasta, seafood, steaks, and pizzas, made with fresh ingredients. Gluten-free pasta is available.
-
Saru Peruvian Joint
Saru Peruvian Joint offers a vibrant menu of traditional Peruvian dishes, including various ceviches, lomo saltado, pollo a la brasa, and other seafood and meat specialties.